- Член од
- 14 јули 2007
- Мислења
- 939
- Поени од реакции
- 27
Дали постои Троја или е само ЕП
По теориите на лингвистот Маргарита, да се размрдаме и ние малку.
Дека Епската Троја не се наоѓа во Турција и не е дел од грчката историја ни го потврдуваат се поголем број научници.
Тhe Trojan War was certainly NOT fought in the small plain near Hissarlik in Turkey and that the search of Homeric Troy in Turkey is a blind alley.
Moreover, since the customs described in the Iliad are typically Celtic, and since Troy's enemies, alternatively called Achaeans, Argives or Danaans, were definitely not ‘Greeks'
Few of Homer's descriptions bear even the vaguest resemblance to the Hissarlik region, and yet rather than search elsewhere for a region that actually does fit the descriptions, scholars have ascribed the mismatch to the poet's fantasy and his utter ignorance of geography.
Origin of the epics should be sought with the Pelasgians, who, according to the Greek historian Herodotus (5th century BC), were a non-Greek people who had founded Athens
Значи грците не ја создале Атина, кој ја создал, тој што и го дал името тАТИНА
The modern day scholar Professor Sir Moses Finley, emeritus of Ancient History at the University of Cambridge - " The opinions of later Greeks and 19th Century scholars are irrelevant. We are confronted with this paradox that the more we know, the worse off we are. Homer's Trojan War must be evicted from the history of the Greek Bronze Age "
Already Professor Flaceliиre noted that 'the metrics of the epics, the dactylic hexameter, seems to be a borrowing, an imitation of a foreign model rather than an invention of the Greeks themselves, since the lines contain an abnormally high proportion of short syllables for their language, and thus require a particular effort on the part of the poet'.
It also appears that Homer's Greek contains a large number of loan words from western European languages, relatively more often from Dutch rather than English, French or German.
Па луге произнесете се.:nesvest:
По теориите на лингвистот Маргарита, да се размрдаме и ние малку.
Дека Епската Троја не се наоѓа во Турција и не е дел од грчката историја ни го потврдуваат се поголем број научници.
Тhe Trojan War was certainly NOT fought in the small plain near Hissarlik in Turkey and that the search of Homeric Troy in Turkey is a blind alley.
Moreover, since the customs described in the Iliad are typically Celtic, and since Troy's enemies, alternatively called Achaeans, Argives or Danaans, were definitely not ‘Greeks'
Few of Homer's descriptions bear even the vaguest resemblance to the Hissarlik region, and yet rather than search elsewhere for a region that actually does fit the descriptions, scholars have ascribed the mismatch to the poet's fantasy and his utter ignorance of geography.
Origin of the epics should be sought with the Pelasgians, who, according to the Greek historian Herodotus (5th century BC), were a non-Greek people who had founded Athens
Значи грците не ја создале Атина, кој ја создал, тој што и го дал името тАТИНА
The modern day scholar Professor Sir Moses Finley, emeritus of Ancient History at the University of Cambridge - " The opinions of later Greeks and 19th Century scholars are irrelevant. We are confronted with this paradox that the more we know, the worse off we are. Homer's Trojan War must be evicted from the history of the Greek Bronze Age "
- The Achaeans built 1186 ships for their attack on Troy, they could have travelled the short distance overland far quicker and cheaper if Troy really had been in the Turkish setting.
- Agamemnon tells us it took him a full month to sail from his kingdom Argos to Ithaca, we know the trip takes less than 24 hours in the Mediterranean setting.
- The mythical location for Troy in Turkey is far too small to accommodate the invading army of about 100,000 men and the long pursuits in horse-drawn chariots.
Already Professor Flaceliиre noted that 'the metrics of the epics, the dactylic hexameter, seems to be a borrowing, an imitation of a foreign model rather than an invention of the Greeks themselves, since the lines contain an abnormally high proportion of short syllables for their language, and thus require a particular effort on the part of the poet'.
It also appears that Homer's Greek contains a large number of loan words from western European languages, relatively more often from Dutch rather than English, French or German.
Па луге произнесете се.:nesvest:
