Ко прво да нагласам за тие што не сакаат да знаат што ќе се случува понатака да не го читаат овој пост
Еве нешто што најдов на една тема за последната епизода од изгубени
Maybe this
is like Final Destination... but hatch-style. Hear me out- out of all the craziness that happened in the hatch in the season two finale, Charlie was the one who's should-have-died type experience (being near that explosion of Eko's) was least deadly. So, Death/the Island is going backwards. Trying to get the people who should have died, starting with the people who's near death experiences were less severe, and working its way in. So, it starts with Charlie, with the lightening, but Desmond saves him, and Death/The Island go to the next one, Mr. Eko, who dies... like he maybe should have trying to blow his way into the hatch. Then it goes back to Charlie, but Desmond saves him again. Maybe Locke is next, having been right in the hatch, but not as close to the failsafe as Desmond? And if it doesn't succeed with Locke, it'll go back to Charlie?
I know the theory is freakishly far-out, but does anyone think I might have something?
And just to add on, this seems like the kind of curve-ball the writers would throw. Let us know someone near and dear will die, practically blatantly tell us it's Charlie, and then have it be Locke or someone else
А еве уште нешто лошо
If Charlie drowned trying to rescue Claire, that means that Claire would've drowned also. Claire is also meant to die? However, Desmond would not want to tell Charlie that Claire is about to die...as Charlie would freak completely...So he told him something a little less traumatic (If that's what it is)
И уште полошо
No one else(except Desmond and Charlie(which was probably gonna die)) was around to save Claire. No one at all even knew she was out there. Remember this...that one lady said that the guy in the red shoes would die eventually...even if she saved him. Claire almost dies, but she's saved. I don't think she's going to be around for much longer.
Aaron is going to die too
remember the psychic who said "this baby need its mother to survive"
Патем не можам да најдам еден пост којшто го прочитав во кој кажуваше дека во Лост не можеме да предвидиме што како ќе биде,и ако го покажат Чарли дека ќе умре,ќе умре некој сосема друг исто како што се мислеше дека Клер би требало да умре а испадна Чарли,мислам дека повторно ќе се измени таа личност и место како во оваа епизода Десмонд кога му кажа на Чарли дека ќе умре,таа личност ќе умре наеднаш така што тоа ќе дојде како бомба
Eве друга теорија
I think I understand what you mean. A linear progression of events that goes like this.
1. Desmond doesn't marry Penny. He goes on a race and gets stuck on the island, pushing the button.
2. He is forced to turn the key.
3. He relives the past, perhaps several times, and only this last time something he did saving the man in the bar got him out of the loop of reliving things.
4. Time continues on.
5. Charlie gets hit by lightening and dies.
6. A second button is found, complete with a second failsafe key.
7. Desmond turns the second key, and like in #3, he starts reliving the past- this time, however, it is the past starting right after #3.
8. Desmond saves Charlie from the lightening, having had a flash of memory about it before it happened.
9. Charlie dies soon after anyway due to drowning.
10. Time continues to the point of finding the next button/key, and Desmond turns the key again, reliving from right after step #3 again.
11. Desmond saves Charlie both from the lightening and the drowning. When it comes to the whole "what he's been through" thing, he's actually mad at Charlie for not understanding that each and every time Desmond saves his life is another time he has relived all of reality trying to save him to make time progress forward, like with the guy in the bar, only to have Charlie die anyway, forcing him to live months of his life again and again, trying to hope saving Charlie one more time will save him from the insanity of this loop.
Meanwhile, we saw only some of these events, and saw them in the order of...
#1
#2
#4
#8
#11
#3
. 
